End-of-Year Fundraising Tips for Nonprofits: Maximize Donor Engagement and Donations

End-of-Year Fundraising Tips for Nonprofits: Maximize Donor Engagement and Donations
When the calendar turns to November, many nonprofits enter one of the most crucial fundraising periods of the year. The holiday spirit, tax benefits, and seasonal giving days create a unique opportunity to drive donations that support mission-driven initiatives. Here are essential year-end fundraising tips to make the most of this giving season and set your nonprofit up for success.

1.    Segment Donor Lists for Targeted Messaging
An effective way to reach donors is by tailoring messages that resonate. Start by pulling your donor lists and segmenting them by factors like donation frequency, donation amount, or specific past campaign involvement. With segmented lists, you can craft personalized messages for each group to increase engagement and the likelihood of donations. For example, you could target major donors with messages about impact-driven milestones and smaller donors with updates about ongoing needs or progress.
 
Benefits of Donor Segmentation:

• Increases Engagement: Personalized messages foster a stronger connection with each group.
• Improves Donation Rates: Targeted appeals are more relevant and impactful.
• Enhances Donor Relationships: Regular, relevant updates make donors feel valued and informed.

 
2.    Review Last Year’s Fundraising Results for SMART Goal Setting
Take a data-driven approach by analyzing previous years’ fundraising performances. Identify which channels (email, social media, direct mail) contributed the most and how different donor segments responded to each campaign. This insight will help you create SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound) goals and set predictable outcomes for this year.
 
SMART Goal-Setting Tips:

• Set Specific Revenue Targets: Define the exact amounts you aim to raise through each channel.
• Measure Campaign Success: Determine engagement rates, average donation amount, and donor retention metrics.
• Keep Goals Achievable: Consider resource availability and adjust goals accordingly.

 
3.    Create a Year-End Marketing and Communications Calendar
An organized marketing calendar is essential to manage the complex end-of-year giving season. Include special dates and events, distribution channels, target audience segments, and clear calls to action for each campaign. Assign team members responsible for each action and track key performance indicators (KPIs) to evaluate effectiveness.
 
Components to Include in Your Calendar:

• Channels and Distribution Dates: Determine when and where your campaign will be shared.
• Audience Segments: Tailor messaging based on donor demographics or donation history.
• Responsibilities: Assign team members to specific tasks.
• KPIs: Track metrics such as funds raised, email open rates, and social engagement.

 
4.    Send a “Loop-Back” Email to All Donors
A “loop-back” email is an effective way to re-engage previous donors. Send an email to donors who contributed in the past, reminding them of their impact and encouraging them to support your mission again this year. Highlight how last year’s donations were utilized and share stories of success.
 
Why Loop-Back Emails Work:

• Builds a Stronger Donor Connection: Donors appreciate hearing about the results of their contributions.
• Encourages Repeat Giving: Sharing impact stories increases the likelihood of renewed support.
• Easily Customizable: Adapt messages based on each donor segment’s past contributions.

 
5.    Gather Stories to Inspire and Share
Donors respond to real stories of lives changed or community improvement. Gather stories from your beneficiaries, staff, or volunteers that exemplify your organization’s impact. These narratives can be shared through emails, social media, or even a dedicated video campaign to bring your mission to life.
 
How to Use Stories Effectively:

• In Email Campaigns: Include a short story with a strong call to action.
• On Social Media: Share stories with engaging visuals or videos for maximum reach.
• During Events: Feature live or recorded testimonials at fundraising events or holiday galas.

 
6.    Send Thanksgiving Gratitude Messages
Thanksgiving offers a perfect time to express your appreciation to all of your generous donors. Utilize “You” language in messages to all of your donors, thanking them for their contributions throughout the year - “Because of You”, “Your Kindness….”, “Your support has made a difference”. This message doesn’t need to or shouldn’t ask for a donation. Expressing gratitude fosters goodwill and reinforces the donors’ sense of purpose and impact.
 
Ideas for a Gratitude Campaign:

• Personalized Emails: Address donors by their name and reference specific campaigns they supported throughout the year. (This is why segmenting your donors is so helpful!)
• Thank-You Videos or Voice Recordings: Share a video message from your organization’s leaders or those impacted by donations. You can also change up your donation thank you’s with a recorded greeting sent as an attachment - these can be highly personal with messages directly from the Executive or Development Director.
• Social Media Shoutouts: Publicly thank donors or recognize notable contributions on all of your social media channels.

​7.    Secure a Matching Gift Opportunity
Donor matches are a powerful way to maximize contributions, as many donors are motivated by the potential to double their impact. Work with major donors or corporate sponsors to set up a matching gift for year-end giving campaigns. Highlight this match in all promotional materials to encourage giving.
 
Matching Gift Tips:

• Highlight the Urgency: Communicate that contributions will be matched only for a limited time.
• Emphasize Impact: Explain how matched gifts significantly amplify impact.
• Share Progress: Update donors on the progress toward the match to encourage contributions.

 
8.    Set Up a Peer-to-Peer Holiday Giving Campaign
Peer-to-peer fundraising engages your supporters in promoting your cause within their personal networks, expanding your reach organically. Equip volunteers, board members, and loyal donors with the tools they need to run mini-campaigns on your behalf. Provide sample social posts and email templates to make it easy for them to ask friends and family for support.
 
Peer-to-Peer Campaign Tips:

• Create Fundraiser Kits: Provide social media assets and email or phone scripts for participants.
• Encourage Friendly Competition: Offer rewards or recognition for top fundraisers.
• Monitor Progress: Track the performance of each peer-to-peer campaign and recognize high achievers.

 
9.    Use Clear Calls-to-Action in All Communications
Every piece of communication should include a clear, compelling call to action (CTA). Whether it’s donating, volunteering, or sharing a story, a CTA should be specific and easy to follow. Phrases like “Donate Now to Double Your Impact” or “Yes - I want to provide affordable housing for families in my community!” are both actionable and inspiring.
 
10.    Focus on Growing Your Donor Base, Not Just the Funds Raised
When evaluating year-end fundraising success, nonprofits often focus on the total amount of funds raised. However, emphasizing the number of new donors can be equally valuable, if not more so.
Attracting new supporters expands your donor base, builds long-term relationships, and boosts future fundraising potential. By welcoming new donors, your organization creates a broader community of advocates and supporters who may contribute regularly, increasing your impact over tie.
Celebrating this growth in new supporters highlights the strength and reach of your mission beyond just dollar amounts - making it feel less transactional, and fostering a stronger, more diverse network of supporters for years to come.
 
 
With thoughtful planning and data-driven approaches, nonprofits can make the most of the end-of-year giving season. By segmenting donor lists, setting clear goals, sharing impactful stories, and expressing gratitude, you can build stronger connections with donors and inspire increased contributions. Utilize these strategies to create a memorable and successful year-end fundraising campaign that sustains your mission well into the coming year.
 
Big Deal Company is proud to support many nonprofits during the end-of-year giving season and beyond, helping organizations maximize their impact through strategic fundraising campaigns and successful event fundraisers. We offer a variety of downloadable resources, expert tips, and best practices, all designed to make your year-end giving campaign a success.

Follow us on social media for event highlights, creative inspiration, and updates on our latest projects.
📘 Facebook | 📸 Instagram | 💼 LinkedIn | ▶️ YouTube  | 📌 Pinterest
​Sign up for our online newsletter to stay updated on the latest insights and tools.

As a collective of experts, BIG DEAL Company specializes in creativity. With superior organization, marketing experience and original ideas, we pull off amazing events and campaigns! 
BIG DEAL Company makes business personal by bringing JOY to the job in everything we do.
​As purveyors of fun with BIG DEAL, we support businesses and individuals in the growth of their ideas, events and marketing strategies. Our creative aptitude allows for unique ideas. Our passion for perfection makes every client a priority! Serving Colorado & Wyoming. We travel too!

Contact BIG DEAL Company
​​*** Bringing Joy to the Job ***
Phone: 970-613-1455  or  303-886-3068
Email Us
Disclosure: *All content produced by My Big Day; DBA Big Deal Company, including websites and content, are the property of My Big Day LLC and protected by U.S. and international copyright laws. You may not copy, reproduce, distribute, transmit, modify, create derivative works, or in any other way exploit any part of our materials without the prior written permission
from My Big Day LLC