Top 7 Silent Auction Items that can Guarantee Fundraising Success!

Silent auctions are a common staple of nonprofit fundraising events. They offer a unique opportunity to engage donors and raise significant funds for a worthy cause.
 
At Big Deal Company, we have first-hand knowledge of what items attract the most interest. We are always on the lookout for that special something that will generate the highest interest and bids!
 
Gone are the days of gift baskets and gift cards. Today’s fundraising auction bidder craves experiences and high-end ticket items. We have a good pulse on what is popular in Northern Colorado (mountain weekend getaways, professional sports packages, etc.). Follow along to see some of the top silent auction items that guest love to bid on nationwide, backed by anecdotes from successful fundraising events to illustrate their impact.

1. Exclusive Vacation Packages Imagine offering a trip to a private island, a chartered fishing trip in an exotic location, or a luxury ski resort. Vacation packages consistently draw high bids due to their unique and experiential nature. For instance, at a recent charity gala supporting children’s education, a week-long stay at a Tuscan villa, including cooking classes and wine tours, sparked a bidding war. The package ultimately sold for $10,000, significantly exceeding expectations and providing essential funds for educational programs. (Charitybuzz. (n.d.). Retrieved from Charitybuzz)

That might be an outlier, but a vacation package that includes a luxurious stay and engaging activities, can garner a lot of excitement. Take some time to research popular travel destinations and pull together a package that will inspire guests to dream and bid!

2. VIP Event Tickets
Tickets to major events, such as the Super Bowl, the Oscars, or Broadway premieres, are always a hit. These items are sought after because they offer access to experiences that are typically hard to come by. At a fundraising dinner for a popular arts nonprofit, VIP tickets to a sold-out Broadway show, including a backstage meet-and-greet with the cast, fetch an astounding $7500, supporting the nonprofit’s outreach initiatives. (BiddingForGood. (n.d.). Retrieved from BiddingForGood)
The Super Bowl or the Oscars might be out of reach, but could you partner with a local business who might have box seats for a local professional sports team - Broncos, Rockies, or Avalanche? Throw in a gift card for dinner out and tickets to a game, and you can easily pull together a winning ticket!
 
3. Celebrity Meet-and-Greets
Donors relish the opportunity to meet their favorite celebrities, whether they are athletes, musicians, or actors. At a silent auction for a healthcare charity, a meet-and-greet with a popular TV star generated immense excitement. The chance to have dinner with the celebrity saw competitive bidding, and pulled in a $5000 contribution in support of medical research! (Charity Navigator. (n.d.). Retrieved from Charity Navigator)
Northern Colorado is a long way from the bright lights of Hollywood, but that doesn’t mean that you can’t make bank on this type of experience! Check with Colorado Sports Teams or Universities - there may be a favorite figure who would be willing to donate an evening with a fan.

4. Unique Artwort
Art can sometimes be a tricky item to auction - after all, beauty is in the eye of the beholder! However, original artwork or signed pieces from well-known artists can often attract art enthusiasts and collectors. A piece by a renowned artist donated to an environmental conservation fundraiser not only drew attention for its beauty but also for its cause. The artwork sold for $8000, funding important projects and raising awareness for the nonprofit’s mission.(Charitybuzz. (n.d.). Retrieved from Charitybuzz)

There are a lot of talented artists in Northern Colorado - perhaps you can add to the package with a pair of tickets to the Denver Art Museum, too?
 
5. Fine Dining Experiences
Exclusive dining experiences, such as a private chef’s dinner or a wine pairing event, are perennial favorites. At a recent silent auction to benefit a homeless shelter, a package that included a private dinner for ten prepared by a Michelin-starred chef, along with a curated win selection, secured a $6000 bid. This experience not only provided a memorable evening for the winning bidder but also significant support for the shelter. (Charitybuzz. (n.d.). Retrieved from Charitybuzz)

Dinners for bidders and their guests also help to further the nonprofit mission. More people are exposed to the mission and brand, and the experience may inspire attendees to donate to the charity in return for a fun evening!
 
6. Luxury Goods
High-end items such as designer handbags, jewelry, and watches are always popular. At a gala for a youth mentorship program, a donated Rolex watch attracted a lot of attention. The bidding was intense, and it ultimately sold for $9000, helping to fund mentorship opportunities and other programs for the nonprofit. (Paddle8. (n.d.). Retrieved from Paddle8)
​
Does your organization have a large and generous donor who has a jewelry collection? This type of partnership is a way to combine planned giving and an event auction for maximum impact! 

7. Sports Memorabilia
Autographed sports memorabilia, such as jerseys, balls, and equipment, are particularly appealing to sports fans. They are extremely popular auction items at golf tournaments!
At a recent fundraiser for a community sports league, a baseball signed by a Hall of Fame player ignited some fierce bidding competition. The item sold for $4500, supporting the league’s efforts to provide sports equipment and facilities for underprivileged youth. (BiddingForGood. (n.d.). Retrieved from BiddingForGood)
 
To maximize the success of your auction, consider the interests and passions of your donors. High-quality, unique items that offer exclusive experiences or rare opportunities tend to attract the highest bid. Additionally, storytelling can enhance the appeal of auction items. Consider enlisting the help of a professional auctioneer to help drum up excitement for the package you are trying to sell. The auctioneer can share anecdotes about how a winning bid will leave a lasting impression in the lives of your organization’s beneficiaries - inspiring more generous bidding!
 
At Big Deal Company, we specialize in curating exceptional silent auction items that will captivate your guests and elevate your fundraising efforts. Let us help you create an unforgettable event that not only raises funds but also deepens engagement with your cause.
Contact us to learn more about our services and how we can help support your next fundraising event.
 

Acquiring New Donors
Acquiring new donors is essential for growth and sustainability. Discover actionable strategies to expand your donor base and engage potential supporters effectively in the following list of tips for donor acquisition:

1. Lead by Example: Every member of your Board of Directors, advisory group, or donor development committee should be contributing to your organization. This demonstrates commitment and inspires confidence in potential donors.
2. Identify Potential Donors: Gather Board Members and Staff asking them to brainstorm and actively identify potential donors within their networks. Everyone can play a role in expanding your donor base.
3. Craft Your Elevator Speech: Develop a short and compelling statement of your organization’s mission, goals, and core beliefs. This ensures you can articulate your ask effectively when engaging with potential donors. For example - think about the issue your organization addresses and simplify it so you can provide a clear and bite-sized answer when someone asks “What do you do?”.
4. Timing is Key: Consider strategic times to make donation requests, such as after-tax time, during Colorado Gives, or at the end of the year when businesses are building out their budgets for the following year.
5. Event Inclusion: Provide clear addresses and maps to facilitate attendance if hosting events. Events - even small gatherings like a donor coffee, offer valuable opportunities for donor engagement.
6. Collaborate with Other Nonprofits: Foster relationships with other nonprofits to exchange ideas and potential cross-connect for fundraising efforts.
7. Innovative Fundraising: Explore alternative fundraising methods, especially for major projects, to diversify your revenue streams.
8. National-Level Donors: Research potential national-level donors who may align with your organization’s mission and vision.
9. Know Your Audience: Spend time researching your audience so that you fully understand the demographics and preferences of who you are speaking to. Tailor your fundraising to match these.
10. DEI Initiatives: If you want to reach a larger audience pool and foster a more inclusive community of supporters, spend some time exploring and embracing diversity, equity, and inclusion practices. Build these into your organization’s values.

As crucial as it is to acquire new donors, fostering meaningful relationships with existing supporters is equally important for the long-term success of any nonprofit. Cultivating these already-established relationships is quite cost effective, and ultimately can turn a one-time donor into a brand ambassador for your organization. In the following section, we’ll delve into strategies aimed at appreciating and engaging current donors to ensure their continued support and commitment to your cause.

​The end of the year is not just a time for holiday festivities and celebrations - it’s also a critical period for nonprofits. It is so critical, that on average, nonprofits raise 26% of their annual revenue in December!
 
A well-executed year-end campaign can set the tone for the upcoming year and provide essential resources for the organization. Nonprofit organizations must pay attention to their fundraising targets during this crucial time. Slash 26% out of anyone’s budget, and the results would be dire!
 
So, what makes an end-of-year campaign a hit and successful? BIG DEAL Company has led multiple successful end-of-year campaigns, and here is what we have found to be some key elements for success:

​Donor-Centric Approaches
It is always helpful to remember that your donors are the heroes. Successful campaigns pull donors along on a journey, showing how their contributions make a difference. Donors like to see their dollars at work and feel like they are making a difference.
 
Lifting up donors during an end-of-year campaign is also key. Personalized thank-you notes and shout-outs on social media can go a long way in making your supporters feel loved and appreciated.

​Multi-Channel Outreach
You need to have a plan to meet your donors where they are. Gone are the days of a single end-of-year mailer or newsletter. Organizations must utilize social media, emails, as well as direct mailers to get their message across. If your organization has an advertising budget, the end-of-year giving season might be the right time to consider purchasing ad space or mailing lists as a way to broaden your audience reach. Different platforms engage people in different ways, so find out what your audience likes and meet them where they are!
 
Create a Communications Plan
Once you have found where your audience receives information, it is vital to set up a communications plan. Prepping your donors well in advance can drastically improve your end-of-year fundraising results. This can be done through emails and social media posts. Prepping communication does not have to ask for money. It just has to serve as a reminder of who you are and what problem you solve. Prepping communication is consistent, engaging, and strategic.

​Transparency
Be open about how the funds will be used. People want to see how their hard-earned money and generosity are making real and tangible impacts.
 
Create Urgency
The clock is ticking and the year is ending!
Create a sense of urgency by taking advantage of pre-planned giving days like #GivingTuesday, or in Northern Colorado, #ColoradoGivesDay.
Build excitement and engagement with a countdown or milestones, encouraging people to act now, rather than later.

​It’s A Match!
According to research from Double the Donation, 84% of donors are more likely to give if they know that their contributions will be matched[1]. 1 in 3 donors indicate that they would give a large gift if matching is applied to their donation[2].
Donors feel that they make a more significant impact on your organization and its cause when they can see their dollars doubled in real-time.
 
Matching Donations can be leveraged by a major donor-matching gift, crowdsourcing matching gifts, or employee/corporate matching gifts. Once you have a plan for a matching gift, it is important that it is communicated clearly with your followers to achieve the greatest impact.
[1] https://doublethedonation.com/statistics/
[2] https://doublethedonation.com/statistics/

​Follow-Up
Once the campaign is over, don’t forget to let everyone know how it went. Celebrate the successes and be honest about the areas where there could be some improvement.
 
It’s also important to be clear with your gratitude. Have a clear plan for how your organization will thank donors at every level - new donors, large donors, small donors, match donors, corporate donors. Giving thanks increases the chances of donors coming back and donating again, setting the foundation for strong and positive relationships.
 
Remember, every donation - big or small - gets you one step closer to your mission’s success. It’s not just about the money - it’s about building a community that shares your values and vision.
 
If you are ready to elevate your organization’s end-of-year fundraising campaign, look no further than BIG DEAL Company. With our proven strategies and experience, we specialize in turning a mission into a compelling story that resonates with donors. We work with organizations to set clear fundraising goals, we design and create engaging multimedia content, and we optimize multi-channel outreach. We also provide robust analytics to help you track campaign performance in real time. Consider working with our team of professionals for your next end-of-year fundraising campaign.